Thursday, July 5, 2012
Does Merida being gay matter?
Which gets us to the question at hand: Is Merida, Heroine of Brave, a lesbian? And if she is, does that matter?
Frankly I think that's one of the dumbest questions raised about this movie. It ignores what actually does matter:
That people are asking the question in the first place.
Okay, let's go over the evidence first:
Merida likes to do boyish things and rejects womanly things. It follows that she is a standin, then, for butch gay women. Of course, Mulan also did boyish things, while wearing boy's clothes and pretending, believe it or not, to be a boy, but her sexuality is above reproach because at the end of the story she ends up with her prince. While we don't have a "Disney Kiss" between Prince and Princess, we do have some assurance that the two love birds will run off into the sunset.
But I'll come back to that in a second. For now we're going to stick with the idea that being boyish means being gay. Which, what does that make Jessie from Toy Story? She's a cowgirl, sure but if the movie wasn't for kids, you know, dear reader, that she'd be swearing as much as the prospector. Belle in Beauty and the Beast is more into her books than the "girly" thing of chasing boys, though I will grant that books can be seen as a different kind of girly.
Thing is, being into boy stuff doesn't make one gay. I've had many students who excelled in athletics, liked cars, went bow hunting, and I'm quite confident more than a few of them were not gay.
Second major data point, as the critics show and I alluded to above, is that Merida is single at the end of the movie, with ne'er a prince in sight. She even gives a moving speech (I told you'd spoil you, but no you had to read anyways) about marrying who she wants on her own terms, not who her parents (or society) tells her to.
Now, this would be a great beacon of her counter-culturalism except that being true to yourself is a hallmark of Disney and children's films. In fact the closing titles of Mulan (back to her again) are indeed the song "True to Your Heart" performed by former Mousketeer Christina Aguilera. Seeking to marry for love carries all through classic as well as modern Disney, from Aladdin to The Little Mermaid. It's just that in those stories the perfect ending happens right now. None of those princesses have to wait for their perfect prince. So Merida has to wait a little. Big deal.
And lastly the movie just happened to premire during Gay Pride Week. So clearly it's all a conspiracy. After all, there are Gay Days at the Disney theme parks, right? Of course while those are not sanctioned officially by the parks, surely they're going to plot to release a movie with a tomboy of a heroine just in time to show their true colors, the whole rainbow if you will.
Or....... it could just be that time of year where you vie to release your summer blockbuster. Tough call.
Now, dear readers, I promised you that I'd tackle the real question.
I believe, fundamentally and as a parent, that it should bother you that this question is being asked.
We have a girl who likes to play rough, prefers bows and arrows to bows and flowers, wants to pick her own partner for life (never saying either way which it is), and demands to live her life on her own terms. And what does the "media" do with it?
They question her sexuality.
What kind of message does this conversation send to our daughters? What are we telling them as they decide they want to ride racing bikes around the neighborhood rather than host a tea party? What are we telling them when they don't want to play the "wife" in a game of house? What are we telling them when they say they want Legos (and I mean real legos not those pink knock offs designed "For girls") instead of Barbie?
We're telling them that those choices will lead to questions about them. Those choices will be examined for "deeper meaning." We're telling them that they should prepare to defend their choices because anything "not normal" demands defense.
I'm not a paragon of this. When my son started at day care, it was mostly boys and yes, he played with dolls. I used to tell the woman, a lovely person who I love dearly as a member of our family, that my son did not "play with dolls"; he was a solider doing relief work and there was administrating humanitarian aid. I always thought that I did so with a wink and a nod and that it was a little joke that I didn't really believe that boys couldn't play with dolls.
But, maybe I failed. Maybe I failed to make it a joke enough. Maybe I made a mistake in even joking about what boys and girls play with.
I don't think my daughter (or son) needs to grow up with people telling her (or him) at every turn what is expected of him because of the accident of his birth. If it's not biologically related, then it's a societal construct and as much as we built up societial rules, we can tear them down. And once in while we have to.
I have nothing but pride (yeah... pride) and support for what Pixar has made, even having yet to see it for myself. I don't doubt at all that they continued to push the envelop for technological innovation and story telling. And even if they simply put out a typical movie, that is still pretty good by most measures.
But what does concern me is the sheer number of bloggers, pundits, talking heads and otherwise Do-Nothings who are making a carreer not only out of fabricating controversy, but doing so in a way that puts the hearts and minds of our daughters at risk.
Grow up, people.